The most popular machine is Coinstar which also lets you exchange your gift cards for cash instantly. Explore other popular stores near you from over 7 million businesses with over 142 million reviews and opinions from Yelpers. 5 Best Ways To Find Old Coins In Circulation Old Coins Coins Valuable Coins Fees may vary by location. Where can i take my old coins for cash . Do not go to a store or jewelry shop that has a big We Buy Gold and Silver sign in the window. Consign to a Sale Today. Which coins are NOT valuable. Ive cashed in over 4000 in coins a couple of time s Reddit user tinyhousebuilder said. 1 Sell to a Coin Shop - Now the coin dealer is going to buy them for less than they are worth and this is normal. If you cant find a local coin dealer try visiting a traveling coin show so you can network with dealers and find someone to buy your coins. They dont have a big enough market. Selling the Rare Coins Youve Inherited 2nd Edition. At the kiosk pick the cash